![]()
|
Karloff, Lugosi, Chaney, Price...all superstars in the Horror Film Hall Of Fame. True fright film icons. Now add to that shuddery list the name of Donald Pleasence. Say what? But yes, we say. Donald Pleasence has made his horror mark in over 50 scary flicks and TV shows--a truly monstrous achievement that might have passed some horror fans by. In order to better understand why Donald Pleasence deserves to stand alongside the likes of Lee and Cushing in the esteem of fright film fans, we're going to turn the spotlight on his career in the next three issues of HORROR-WOOD. In this way, we can all learn to appreciate...
By HARVEY F. CHARTRAND (Note: This is the first article in a three-part series that examines the huge horror film output of actor Donald Pleasance. Part Two of this series will appear in next month's issue.) Ten years after his death at age 75, Donald Pleasence can be ranked as one of the great kings of horror, right up there with Karloff, Carradine, Chaney, Lugosi and Price. Pleasences output in the horror genre was nothing short of protean: 53 films and TV shows demonstrate the English actors mastery at portraying characters menacing, misanthropic, malevolent, murderous and megalomaniacal. All the more extraordinary as Pleasences physical appearance was unprepossessing he was bald, unattractive and of slight build. And yet Pleasence had talent to burn and that mysterious indefinable something that commanded the viewers attention. That grim countenance and those piercing eyes! The camera loved him.
"Theres a certain malevolence about Donald Pleasence that never fails to amuse me," observed film critic Roger Ebert in a 1976 review of I Dont Want To Be Born. "Hes small and bald and beady-eyed, with a mouth that surrenders each word with the greatest reluctance. He always seems to be holding something back--and somehow, Id rather not know what." Through his entire 43-year career in movies and TV, Pleasence never stopped working. To quote from a 1989 Fangoria story by Marc Shapiro: "Pleasences need for the green and his ability to add chills to chillers resulted in his lending support to a ton of horror and fantasy-tinged titles." These were wildly uneven in quality, ranging from the sublime (Halloween) to the ridiculous (Frankenstein's Great Aunt Tillie).
Film critic Leonard Maltin writes that Pleasence was often cited as the busiest actor in the world. "There seemed to be no part this bald, big-eyed, creepy-looking little Englishman wouldnt take," Maltin notes. All told, Pleasence appeared in 210 films and TV shows from 1952 until his death in 1995. A few of these productions are classic, but many of them are worthless. In some of his more obscure foreign-made films, Pleasence is the only recognizable name in the cast. Not unlike actor/director Orson Welles (with whom he co-starred in Where Is Parsifal? in 1983), Pleasence dreaded downtime and would flit from one project to the next, lending his once classy name to the most atrocious garbage. From 1980 on, Pleasence would no longer appear in A-pictures like The Great Escape or Fantastic Voyage. And that is a great pity for an actor of such astonishing talent.
Pleasences first foray into horror was by way of the 1954 BBC TV version of George Orwells dystopian vision of the future--1984. Pleasence registered strongly as Syme, the dedicated bureaucrat in charge of the Newspeak Department, which invents new words and destroys old ones. Syme boasts that Newspeak will eventually replace the literature of the past, reducing the range of thought and vocabulary and opposition to the State (as represented by the all-seeing, omniscient Big Brother). Yet the devoted Syme is accused of "thoughtcrime" and becomes a pariah. Peter Cushing plays Orwells doomed hero Winston Smith. Pleasence has several memorable encounters with Cushing in scenes set in a canteen. The shifty and unknowable nature of Symes character (is he friend or foe?) really comes across in Pleasences ambiguous portrayal. Later, Symes complete breakdown and his pleas to Smith, who quickly abandons him for fear of being incriminated, are a powerful contrast to the characters cool, controlled and implacable manner in the earlier scenes. If Syme--a party man through and through who loved his corrupting work of destroying words for Big Brother--can be accused of thoughtcrime, then no one is safe.
Pleasence is the only actor to have appeared in two different adaptations of Orwells seminal novel. In Michael Andersons 1956 film noir version of 1984, Pleasence is cast as Parsons--Smith's fellow employee at the Ministry of Truth. Orwell describes Parsons as "a fattish but active man of paralyzing stupidity, a mass of imbecile enthusiasms--one of those completely unquestioning, devoted drudges on whom, more even than on the Thought Police, the stability of the Party depended." Parsons is also turned over to Big Brother for unspecified crimes against the State. This time, Pleasence played his scenes in the canteen with beefy American character actor Edmond OBrien, miscast as Smith for his marquee value. Pleasence makes his first real mark on the world of horror in 1959s The Flesh and the Fiends. He steals the show as the scheming and insidious 19th-century grave robber and murderer William Hare, who provided fresh corpses to medical researcher Dr. Robert Knox (Peter Cushing). Eventually, there is a shortage of cadavers, so Hare and his equally disreputable partner William Burke (George Rose) decide they cant simply wait around for people to die of natural causes.
They must hasten the process along to increase the supply--snuffing out the lives of those drunkards and beggars who litter the murky alleyways of Edinburgh, Scotland. After asphyxiating their victims, Burke and Hare tote them in packing crates to the misguided doctors clinic, eagerly collecting the blood money so they can go off on another drunken spree. Pleasence is unforgettable as the sleazy body snatcher. Who cannot be thoroughly repulsed by Hares crudeness, greasy preening, raggedy mountebank costumes and completely conscienceless malice, asks film critic Glenn Erickson in his review for DVD Savant.
Underrated and overlooked for decades, The Flesh And The Fiends (aka Mania) is now widely regarded as a horror classic, ranking with the best early Hammer Film Productions (although it was actually produced by Triad Productions). In Circus of Horrors (1960), Pleasence has a small but key role as Vanet, the alcoholic owner of a rundown circus in France. A grateful Vanet transfers ownership of the circus to fugitive plastic surgeon Dr. Bernard Schueler (Anton Diffring) after he transforms his disfigured little daughter into a perky gamine.
Schueler inherits the whole show when Vanet, in his cups, hugs a Russian bear and is mauled to death--an unintentionally hilarious scene, as it is obvious that Pleasence is wrestling with a man in a floppy bear suit. Yet Circus of Horrors is a crisp, handsome and stylish movie shocker that holds up well 45 years after its release. In the third remake of The Hands Of Orlac (1961), Mel Ferrer is cast as concert pianist Stephen Orlac, whose life goes to hell after his hands are badly burned in a plane crash. Surgeons tell him they saved his hands, but the unhinged Orlac believes the doctors used him for a transplant experiment, grafting onto him the hands of a freshly executed serial strangler. Orlacs new hands start to take on a life of their own. Pleasence appears in a choice cameo as Graham Coates, an eccentric artist who wants to use Orlacs hands as the model for his latest work.
Pleasence turns up next in The Confession, a 1961 episode of the supernatural anthology series Alcoa Presents: One Step Beyond, hosted by John Newland. Pleasence plays a Crown prosecutor who rests badly after an innocent man is executed. Pleasence has his first lead role in Dr. Crippen (1962), the real-life story of Dr. Hawley Harvey Crippen, who was hanged in London in 1910 after poisoning his wife, dismembering her body and burying the remains in the coal cellar of their home. Dr. Crippen attempted to flee England with his much younger mistress (Samantha Eggar), only to be arrested aboard ship while en route to North America. Pleasence is brilliant as the mild-mannered, middle-aged quack doctor, driven to murder by his overbearing wife (Coral Browne), a failed music-hall performer with an eye for younger men.
In the 1962 horror comedy What A Carve Up (aka No Place Like Homicide), a shy manuscript reader (Carry On series regular Kenneth Connor) is invited to an old, creepy mansion for the reading of his uncle's will. After he arrives, murders begin to happen. Pleasence plays Everett Sloane--the sinister solicitor in charge of the reading of the will. This variation on The Old Dark House is by turns ghoulish and guffaw-inducing. Blimey! In the early 1960s, Pleasence went Stateside to work, so he was available for a nostalgic episode of The Twilight Zone entitled The Changing of the Guard, written by Rod Serling. Made up to look twice his age, Pleasence stars as Professor Ellis Fowler, the oldest teacher at the exclusive Rock Springs School for Boys. Ordered by his headmaster to retire after 51 years of service, the dejected Fowler is convinced that his life has been rendered meaningless and contemplates suicide until he is paid a nocturnal visit by several ethereal-looking "alumni." The episode (the third season finale) was telecast on June 1, 1962.
In The Man with the Power episode of The Outer Limits (1963), Pleasence is well cast as a milquetoast type given destructive telekinetic powers during a NASA experiment in mind control. Harold J. Finley, a professor at a second-rate college, despises his job and uncaring wife and dreams of joining the space program. (At this juncture of his career, Pleasence specialized in "quiet desperation" roles.) Prof. Finley devises a means of mentally harnessing ambient cosmic energy into a focused beam, gradually transforming the discrete beams into psychokinetic lightning bolts directed at his enemies. In George Stevens biblical epic The Greatest Story Ever Told (1964), Pleasence drips evil as the serpent-like Dark Hermit (aka Satan), smoothly tempting the fasting Jesus (Max von Sydow) with food and power on a mountain precipice in the wilderness. Pleasences bald pate and hypnotic eye resurface throughout the film, as he stalks the Christ in scenes of profound eeriness that are completely at odds with the reverent tone of the rest of the film. No longer quietly desperate, Pleasence is at his diabolical best in The Greatest Story Ever Told.
Eye Of The Devil/13 (1967) is an underrated fantasy with a dream cast--Pleasence, David Niven, Deborah Kerr, David Hemmings and Sharon Tate. Aristocratic French vineyard owner marquis Philippe de Montfaucon is called back to his chateau. He asks his wife Catherine to remain in London, but she follows him to France and soon discovers that her husbands employees are following old pagan rituals that call for the life of the marquis to be ritualistically sacrificed to save the crops after another dry season. Apparently, Eye of the Devil was badly re-edited before its initial release, which may explain why the plot is somewhat muddled. Still, the solid horror premise has Kerr finding herself in a strange, isolated community with odd beliefs (the same basic setup as The Wicker Man). Head shaved completely bald, Pleasence plays Père Dominic, a menacing Catholic priest allied with the pagan cult.
Around this time, Pleasence was Michael Reeves first choice for the role of Matthew Hopkins-- Witchfinder General (aka The Conqueror Worm/1968), but American International Pictures insisted on the more bankable Vincent Price instead. Pleasence then appears in the first of several made-in-Canada movies. However, Creature Of Comfort (1968) has never been released. Nor is it ever likely to be, as it is a lost film. Creature Of Comfort is the tale of a giant amoeba-like entity that absorbs mean and selfish people when they use it on their beds as a comforter. Pleasence appears in the linking story as the man who owns the sinister store that sells the creature. Somehow, after each absorption, the mega-amoeba finds its way back to the store, to be sold to yet another miscreant. Creature of Comfort sounds like an urban legend, but apparently it was actually filmed in Toronto, according to actor/writer Laird Stuart, who wrote the screenplay.
While Pleasence rarely turned down film parts, he did pass on the role of Britain's notorious serial murderer John Christie in Richard Fleischer's 1971 suspense drama 10 Rillington Place. After having already played Dr. Crippen, Pleasence feared the role of Christie would further stereotype him as a film psychotic. Richard Attenborough, who co-starred with Pleasence in The Great Escape, took the part and played it most effectively. In Death Line/Raw Meat (1972), Pleasence is perfectly cast as an irritable and sarcastic police inspector investigating a series of gruesome killings committed by a lonely cannibal living in the disused tunnels of the London Underground. Pleasences outstanding performance as Inspector Calhoun adds a welcome comic tonic to the grim and seedy proceedings. Another bonus: in a cameo as a Whitehall Foreign Service officer, a mustachioed Christopher Lee exchanges stinging insults with Pleasence. Seeing these two acting legends sharing screen time is horror heaven!
That same year, Pleasence co-stars as a greedy baron in The Pied Piper, director Jacques Demys dark vision of the Hamelin legend. Pop singer Donovan plays the Fourteenth Century piper hired by duplicitous burgomaster Pleasence to rid the town of its teeming rat population. Demy's trend-setting depiction of medieval Europe as a squalid, vermin-infested hole was duplicated in many films, including Monty Python and the Holy Grail (1975), Jabberwocky (1977), Anazapta (2001) and Kingdom Of Heaven (2005). Incidentally, all those rats in The Pied Piper are real (just check the title credit for the rat wrangler). Donovans one-note portrayal notwithstanding, The Pied Piper is an unheralded classic just waiting to be rediscovered via DVD. Thanks, Harv. While this early segment of Donald Pleasence's remarkable film career may have ended with rats, certainly, no one was saying "Rats!" to him. He was already a familiar and favorite face in horror films, and the most memorable of his horror film roles were yet to come. We'll examine the fright flicks that made Donald Pleasance a horror film star in the next segment of your series in next month's issue. Article copyright © Harvey F. Chartrand |
